YomKippur2013

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Sunday, September 8, 2013

A war the Pentagon doesn’t want

Posted on 5:16 AM by Unknown

Robert H. Scales

Robert H. Scales, a retired Army major general, is a former commandant of the U.S. Army War College.
 
The tapes tell the tale. Go back and look at images of our nation’s most senior soldier, Gen. Martin Dempsey, and his body language during Tuesday’s Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearings on Syria. It’s pretty obvious that Dempsey, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, doesn’t want this war. As Secretary of State John Kerry’s thundering voice and arm-waving redounded in rage againstBashar al-Assad’s atrocities, Dempseywas largely (and respectfully) silent.

Dempsey’s unspoken words reflect the opinions of most serving military leaders. By no means do I profess to speak on behalf of all of our men and women in uniform. But I can justifiably share the sentiments of those inside the Pentagon and elsewhere who write the plans and develop strategies for fighting our wars. After personal exchanges with dozens of active and retired soldiers in recent days, I feel confident that what follows represents the overwhelming opinion of serving professionals who have been intimate witnesses to the unfolding events that will lead the United States into its next war.

They are embarrassed to be associated with the amateurism of the Obama administration’s attempts to craft a plan that makes strategic sense.
None of the White House staff has any experience in war or understands it. So far, at least, this path to war violates every principle of war, including the element of surprise, achieving mass and having a clearly defined and obtainable objective.
They are repelled by the hypocrisy of a media blitz that warns against the return of Hitlerism but privately acknowledges that the motive for risking American lives is our “responsibility to protect” the world’s innocents. Prospective U.S. action in Syria is not about threats to American security. The U.S. military’s civilian masters privately are proud that they are motivated by guilt over slaughters in Rwanda, Sudan and Kosovo and not by any systemic threat to our country.

They are outraged by the fact that what may happen is an act of war and a willingness to risk American lives to make up for a slip of the tongue about “red lines.” These acts would be for retribution and to restore the reputation of a president. Our serving professionals make the point that killing more Syrians won’t deter Iranian resolve to confront us. The Iranians have already gotten the message.

Our people lament our loneliness. Our senior soldiers take pride in their past commitments to fight alongside allies and within coalitions that shared our strategic goals. This war, however, will be ours alone.
They are tired of wannabe soldiers who remain enamored of the lure of bloodless machine warfare. “Look,” one told me, “if you want to end this decisively, send in the troops and let them defeat the Syrian army. If the nation doesn’t think Syria is worth serious commitment, then leave them alone.” But they also warn that Syria is not Libya or Serbia. Perhaps the United States has become too used to fighting third-rate armies. As the Israelis learned in 1973, the Syrians are tough and mean-spirited killers with nothing to lose.
Our military members understand and take seriously their oath to defend the constitutional authority of their civilian masters. They understand that the United States is the only liberal democracy that has never been ruled by its military. But today’s soldiers know war and resent civilian policymakers who want the military to fight a war that neither they nor their loved ones will experience firsthand.
Civilian control of the armed services doesn’t mean that civilians shouldn’t listen to those who have seen war. Our most respected soldier president, Dwight Eisenhower, possessed the gravitas and courage to say no to war eight times during his presidency. He ended the Korean War and refused to aid the French in Indochina; he said no to his former wartime friends Britain and France when they demanded U.S. participation in the capture of the Suez Canal. And he resisted liberal democrats who wanted to aid the newly formed nation of South Vietnam. We all know what happened after his successor ignored Eisenhower’s advice. My generation got to go to war.
Over the past few days, the opinions of officers confiding in me have changed to some degree. Resignation seems to be creeping into their sense of outrage. One officer told me: “To hell with them. If this guy wants this war, then let him have it. Looks like no one will get hurt anyway.”
Soon the military will salute respectfully and loose the hell of hundreds of cruise missiles in an effort that will, inevitably, kill a few of those we wish to protect. They will do it with all the professionalism and skill we expect from the world’s most proficient military. I wish Kerry would take a moment to look at the images from this week’s hearings before we go to war again.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The complex legality of settlements
    PETER WERTHEIM The misuse of international law as a tool of political condemnation is especially unhelpful right now.   For David Kretzmer...
  • Yup Obama has Israel's back-read on...
    U.S. spy network’s successes, failures and objectives detailed in ‘black budget’ summary By Barton Gellman and Greg M...
  • Syrian Diplomacy?
    Barry Rubin On September 11, 2013 The idea of a diplomatic solution to the Syrian crisis is ideal for the Obama Administration, but that...
  • Peace Talks: What Is Behind The Palestinian Message?
    Khaled Abu Toameh For now, the Palestinian Authority's strategy is to continue talking while at the same time blaming Israel for the l...
  • Rethinking the Two-State Solution
    PolicyWatch 1408     Giora Eiland and Martin Indyk Also available in ...
  • Eliminate Israel and replace it with an Arab-majority nation?
      Jonathan Tobin The New York Times just spent 2,300 words outlining how -- and why -- it should be done JewishWorldReview.com |   Twenty ye...
  • Libyan Muslim Brotherhood opens door to conciliation
    Khalid Mahmoud   Libyan Brotherhood deny they were against Zaidan's government since his appointment, and will decide whether to stay ...
  • Kuwait Funding Muslim Brotherhood Growth in Western Mosques
    Abigail R. Esman Special to IPT News September 13, 2013 http://www.investigativeproject.org/4160/kuwait-funding-muslim-brotherhood-growth-in...
  • Analysis: Are Syrian and Iranian threats just bluster?
    By ARIEL BEN SOLOMON   US military expert says Syria is capable of attacking Israel, as it has hundreds of...
  • British commander to Post: Russian-US plan for Syria ‘not realistic’
    YAAKOV LAPPIN 09/16/2013 Former commander of British forces in Afgha...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ▼  September (234)
      • Eliminate Israel and replace it with an Arab-major...
      • Saudi Daily: 'Chemical Weapons Smuggled to Hezbollah'
      • Livni 'Willing to Cede Control of Jordan Valley'
      • A Taxi Ride down Syria Street
      • The Military Option and Disarmament Diplomacy with...
      • Obama's YouTube Wars Posted
      • Really? It's only about the money or are you afrai...
      • PIP: Abbas: Meet Our Conditions, Then We Can Have ...
      • Media Silent as Muslims Ethnically Cleanse 60,000 ...
      • British commander to Post: Russian-US plan for Syr...
      • "Who Are They Kidding?"
      • An Anchorless World
      • The Decline and Fall of the American Empire
      • Going into elections, Merkel says support for Isra...
      • Report: Syria transferring chemical weapons to Ira...
      • Video Reveals Key Iranian Role in Syrian Civil War
      • Omar Rivera Urinates on the Wall of the Steinway S...
      • COP: Hillary! Because What Difference Does it Make?
      • The complex legality of settlements
      • Yossi Beilin: PM Rabin did not consult with securi...
      • Update to earlier report: MK Liberman: Israel has ...
      • Startling Parallels: Obama Appeasement Policy and ...
      • "The Saudis are Trembling - Quietly"‏
      • Beware Syrians Bearing Gifts
      • Post Yom Kippur: iEngage: The meaningful quiet of...
      • Putin Set-up Obama and Kerry for the Spike in 2014
      • Louisiana: Newspaper features Muslim cover story o...
      • Golda Meir protocols from Agranat Commission released
      • FRAMEWORK FOR ELIMINATION OF SYRIAN CHEMICAL WEAPONS
      • FSA Spokesman: Syria shifts chemicals to Iraq and ...
      • NY: CAIR gets man fired from Walmart, re-educates ...
      • Gmar Hatima Tova
      • "Moderate" Fatah opens fire on soldiers protecting...
      • Swedish City Overrun by Muslim Crime Turns to Supe...
      • Spain: Jihadists Threaten Catalonia over Burqa Ban
      • Syria-related Misconceptions, Inconsistencies and ...
      • THE MILITARY OPTION AND DISARMAMENT DIPLOMACY WITH...
      • Kuwait Funding Muslim Brotherhood Growth in Wester...
      • Yom Kippur-2013
      • The Holiest Day of the Year: How IDF Soldiers Obse...
      • Benghazi: One Year Later
      • Afghanistan: Islamic jihadists murder 3, wound 10 ...
      • Egypt's War On Hamas
      • "Tired of War"
      • Opinion: Maneuvering, Iranian Style
      • Israel's twenty year nightmare
      • "Yom Kippur"
      • Muslim Persecution of Christians: June, 2013
      • Where we are is bad and it hurts. Which way from h...
      • Israel, Abandon The "Peace Talks" Now
      • You can fool some of the people. . .
      • UN report on Middle East, illustrated
      • Hamas gives landmines to Egyptian Islamists, train...
      • Bizarre Israeli ruling that PA does not practice i...
      • Russia-Iran Axis Gets Accesss|
      • Patterns and Incidents
      • Attn UK friends -- Abdel-Bari Atwan advocates chem...
      • When Privileged Western Undergrads Blindly Promote...
      • Palestinian Rioters Attack Security Personnel near...
      • Obama’s Iran Blind Spot
      • The Mandate For Palestine Still Relevant Nearly A ...
      • U.N. Pretzel & Media Twist
      • An Unintended Legacy
      • Bulgaria: Death of Israelis, Bulgarian driver ‘our...
      • "International Farce"
      • Twenty Years to Oslo
      • A September Evening
      • Surprised? Shouldn't be!!
      • Syrian Diplomacy?
      • More Than a Memorial Day
      • America’s Isolationism and its Implications for Is...
      • Syria Tells You Everything You Need to Know About ...
      • Libyan Muslim Brotherhood opens door to conciliation
      • How to Respond to Palestinian Propaganda
      • Libyan Government Commemorates September 11 by Ref...
      • From the ME: In Syria, Putin's the Player and Obam...
      • Why Israelis See Shi'ite Axis as a Greater Threat ...
      • Stephens: The Bed Obama and Kerry Made
      • HOW TO MAKE THE BEST OUT OF RUSSIA'S FLAWED PLAN F...
      • Time Favors Israel-The Resilient Jewish State
      • The anti-Israel media, chemical weapons, and Israel
      • Terrorism in Judea and Samaria Becoming More Sophi...
      • Fatah: Replace today's "whores" with yesterday's k...
      • Peace Talks: What Is Behind The Palestinian Message?
      • Voting for 'victims'
      • Sending Messages to Tehran
      • Obama Administration: The New Seven Pillars of Wis...
      • The Syrian Crisis As Reflected In Cartoons In The ...
      • Yemeni child bride dies of internal injuries
      • What is Israel’s interest in Syria?
      • Syrian 'rebels' threaten Christians with death if ...
      • International Body of Experts Collaborates With th...
      • Can we clone Tony Abbott, please?
      • Here's where it began: RUSSIA TO PUSH SYRIA TO SUR...
      • Are non Al Qaeda Syrian Rebels ‘Moderate’?
      • Out of the frying pan into the farce‏
      • Obama says Russian proposal on Syria a potential '...
      • "Amazing!"
      • COP: The Journey from Left to Right….
      • Benghazi whistleblower says he's been punished for...
      • Going to War with the Blind General of Benghazi (A...
      • Russia pre-empts Obama-bet he never saw it coming!!
      • Barack Obama’s delusions of grandeur: compares Syr...
      • The battle of the bloggers
      • PA libel: Israel spreads drugs to harm Palestinians
      • From a Small Village in Africa to an Officer in th...
      • Shooting the Syrian Elephant
      • The Biggest Mega-Mosque in Scandinavia
      • Why Syria's Minorities Support Assad
      • Thailand: Islamic jihad has resulted in 5,000+ dea...
      • A New Muslim Brotherhood Symbol: R4BIA
      • The Myth of the Moderate Syrian Rebels
      • 'Obama Administration: The New Seven Pillars of "W...
      • Alliance with Israel growing out of Egyptian secur...
      • Has the EU abandoned the US on military action in ...
      • Why AIPAC might be backing Obama.
      • An Air Strike Imperative
      • Why America Is Saying 'No'
      • "Adjusting Sites"
      • ANTI-ISRAELISM AND ANTISEMITISM IN SOCIAL MEDIA, A...
      • Another Judicial Victory for the Israeli Fascist Left
      • A war the Pentagon doesn’t want
      • Big Fat Red Line
      • Revealed: Britain sold nerve gas chemicals to Syri...
      • Wake up World: Photos Of Children Fighting In Syr...
      • Hate Jews Much?
      • In Pictures: Christian Copts Stand Firm in Midst o...
      • How to Tell the "Good Guys" in Syria‏
    • ►  August (266)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile