YomKippur2013

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Saturday, August 31, 2013

Rethinking the Two-State Solution

Posted on 5:34 AM by Unknown

PolicyWatch 1408
 
 
Giora Eiland and Martin Indyk
Also available in العربية
Policy #1408
October 3, 2008-reposted Aug. 31, 2013

On September 23, 2008, Maj. Gen. (Ret.) Giora Eiland and Ambassador Martin Indyk addressed a Policy Forum luncheon at The Washington Institute. General Eiland is former head of the Israeli National Security Council and currently a senior researcher at the Institute for National Security Studies in Tel Aviv. Ambassador Indyk directs the Saban Center for Middle East Policy at the Brookings Institution. The following is a rapporteur’s summary of their remarks.


GIORA EILAND
Within the Israeli-Palestinian conflict lies a paradox. Although the two-state solution is well known and widely accepted, and although there is international consensus regarding the need for it, little progress has been made to that end. This means that neither side desires the solution nor is willing to take the necessary risks to move forward and come to an agreement. Ultimately, the most the Israeli government can offer the Palestinians -- and survive politically -- is far less than what any Palestinian leadership can accept. As such, there is a gap between the two sides that continues to widen as the years go on.

In many aspects, the current situation is worse than it was eight years ago. In 2000, there were three leaders who were both determined and capable of reaching an agreement: U.S. president Bill Clinton, Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak, and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat. That type of leadership is missing today. In addition, while the two sides enjoyed a reasonable level of security, cooperation, and trust in 2000, the subsequent intifada has created a completely different situation on the ground today. The rise of Hamas also poses a serious threat to any potential solution. Hamas was an opposition group in 2000, and the Palestinian Authority was capable of acting against its will. Today, it seems that even if Hamas were to lose control of Gaza and its majority in the Palestinian legislature, it would be strong enough politically and militarily to undermine any political agreement. Finally, there are a growing number of Israeli settlers in the West Bank that the Israeli government may not be willing or even capable of evacuating.

On what basis can one believe that what failed eight years ago during optimal circumstances could possibly be successful today when the situation is much worse? It has become clear that the conventional two-state solution -- the establishment of two independent states between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea -- is not attractive enough for either side to move forward. Thus, in order to avoid prolonging the conflict, it is necessary to modify the solution in the hope of persuading both parties to take additional risks or make further concessions.

One variation is to give Jordan security responsibility for the West Bank. It would be preferable to give this role to Jordan rather than to the Palestinian Authority for one main reason: Hamas. There is valid concern that if a Palestinian state were established in the West Bank, Hamas would inevitably gain control. Contracting out the security responsibility to Jordan while ensuring Palestinian political autonomy could prevent the threat Hamas poses to Israel. Moreover, in light of Hamas's control of Gaza, if a state were established in the West Bank, Palestinians might be more prepared to live under Jordan than Hamas.

The other alternative is a regional solution. The conventional two-state solution leaves two major problems unsolved: the daunting prospect of evacuating roughly 100,000 Israelis from the West Bank and Gaza's lack of the necessary land and resources to be part of a viable state. Ultimately, the need is for more space -- the one thing the Arab world can provide. Thus, the problem could be solved with a multilateral land swap involving Egypt, Israel, and the Palestinian territories. Egypt could cede a modest amount of land to significantly increase the size of the Gaza Strip. Israel would then keep a percentage of the West Bank equal to the amount of land being given by Egypt to Gaza. In return, Israel would grant an equivalent part of the Negev desert to Egypt and create a direct corridor from Egypt to Jordan.

Although many of the core issues of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict are difficult, the main inhibitors are territory and security. The piece of land in question is simply too small and too inadequate to satisfy both sides, and it is up to neighboring states to make their own contributions if a two-state solution is to succeed. If this option does not seem feasible, it is necessary to come up with alternative resolutions to the conflict. Bridging the ever widening gap between the two sides will be impossible if the obsession with only one solution persists. Instead of continuing with the same approach that has repeatedly failed in the past, it is time to explore other possibilities. Otherwise, the solution will continue to elude us -- even though everybody wants it.

MARTIN INDYK
Although Giora Eiland offers interesting ideas, they are not viable options. His challenge to provide alternative solutions is important, but he takes a quintessentially Western approach to the situation. Americans are drawn to it out of the belief that every problem has a solution, but his solutions are inherently flawed.

In terms of the Jordanian option, ultimately no Jordanian government would be willing to take over from Israel the responsibility for policing Palestinians. West Bank Palestinians pose a demographic threat to Jordanians. Furthermore, Eiland moves past the issue of Palestinian identity too quickly in suggesting that Palestinians in the West Bank would be willing to accept a Jordanian national identity. It is highly doubtful the Palestinians would easily consent to this. As for the regional option, Arab states have historically been unwilling to engage in this type of solution. Given Egypt's insistence that the tiny Sinai border area of Taba be brought to international arbitration in the 1980s, it is unrealistic to expect the Egyptians to willingly give up any territory in the Sinai for the sake of their Palestinian neighbors.

At this point, it seems that Israelis and Palestinians cannot achieve a two-state solution alone; third-party intervention is necessary to establish a lasting peace. Egypt and Jordan -- the two Arab neighbors most directly affected by this situation -- are contributing, but perhaps less than Washington would like. Still, from Egypt's role in negotiating a ceasefire and policing the border with Gaza, to Jordan's training of Palestinian security services, their contributions should not be underestimated. Their involvement is helping create circumstances that may make a two-state solution more viable. We must try to support those who have the will to make peace and strengthen their capabilities. We have helped the Jordanians, but while some progress is being made, that assistance is not enough. The participation of the rest of the Arab states is essential to moving the process forward.

Nevertheless, the progress since Israel made peace with Egypt prevails over the aforementioned obstacles. At a minimum, Israel enjoys peace with Egypt and Jordan, and Israeli governments have made great strides in accepting the two-state solution. Also, although Hamas is ascendant, one can argue that it is gradually coming to terms with Israel's reality, as demonstrated by the informal ceasefires negotiated with Israel in Gaza. Furthermore, most of the problems Eiland raises are actually amenable to solutions, but require political will on both sides. Obstacles such as the mass evacuation of Israeli settlers and the refugee problem are not insurmountable. They require courageous leadership and a willingness to speak the truth to one's people.

The more doubts that are raised and the more alternatives that are offered, the better the two-state solution looks. Palestinian and Israeli governments have had serious negotiations in the past year and have arrived back at the point they were in 2000 after the development of the Clinton parameters. This progression proves the viability of the basic ideas that Clinton presented eight years ago. In the long term, this is not the moment to abandon the two-state solution: It is the time to inject the effort with greater urgency.

This rapporteur's summary was prepared by Sana Mahmood.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The complex legality of settlements
    PETER WERTHEIM The misuse of international law as a tool of political condemnation is especially unhelpful right now.   For David Kretzmer...
  • Yup Obama has Israel's back-read on...
    U.S. spy network’s successes, failures and objectives detailed in ‘black budget’ summary By Barton Gellman and Greg M...
  • Syrian Diplomacy?
    Barry Rubin On September 11, 2013 The idea of a diplomatic solution to the Syrian crisis is ideal for the Obama Administration, but that...
  • Peace Talks: What Is Behind The Palestinian Message?
    Khaled Abu Toameh For now, the Palestinian Authority's strategy is to continue talking while at the same time blaming Israel for the l...
  • Rethinking the Two-State Solution
    PolicyWatch 1408     Giora Eiland and Martin Indyk Also available in ...
  • Eliminate Israel and replace it with an Arab-majority nation?
      Jonathan Tobin The New York Times just spent 2,300 words outlining how -- and why -- it should be done JewishWorldReview.com |   Twenty ye...
  • Libyan Muslim Brotherhood opens door to conciliation
    Khalid Mahmoud   Libyan Brotherhood deny they were against Zaidan's government since his appointment, and will decide whether to stay ...
  • Kuwait Funding Muslim Brotherhood Growth in Western Mosques
    Abigail R. Esman Special to IPT News September 13, 2013 http://www.investigativeproject.org/4160/kuwait-funding-muslim-brotherhood-growth-in...
  • Analysis: Are Syrian and Iranian threats just bluster?
    By ARIEL BEN SOLOMON   US military expert says Syria is capable of attacking Israel, as it has hundreds of...
  • British commander to Post: Russian-US plan for Syria ‘not realistic’
    YAAKOV LAPPIN 09/16/2013 Former commander of British forces in Afgha...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  September (234)
    • ▼  August (266)
      • The Obama Doctrine: Right is might
      • France: A "Secularism Charter" in Every School
      • Bombing Into Unintended Consequences in Syria
      • Into The Fray: David Harris’s ‘stunning shortsight...
      • Israel's only two options
      • Rethinking the Two-State Solution
      • The Two State Concept is Wrong
      • Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood supporters place X marks...
      • The Kurds Can Lead a Reborn Syria, At Peace With A...
      • COP: The Legacy of Liberalism
      • For It and Against It
      • Spokesman for Catholic Church in Egypt: “Shame on ...
      • Syria Claims Terrorists Behind WMD Attack Will Car...
      • Op-Ed: Terrible Days are Coming Upon Europe
      • Tension and skepticism as Obama nears Syria moment
      • Why Is Obama Contemplating Military Strike On Syri...
      • US Admin Seeks Green Light to Respond Militarily t...
      • Latest NYT Denunciation of Israel
      • Yup Obama has Israel's back-read on...
      • U.S. Attack on Syria Won't Change Anything
      • Why So Many Palestinian High-Tech Entrepreneurs Ha...
      • The Al Dura Case: White Hats, Black Hats, and Dunc...
      • Obama's bread and circuses
      • How Obama Hugged the Brotherhood to Death
      • Who are the neo-con cowboys now?
      • What Barack Obama Can Learn from Israel about Conf...
      • Iran commander: US strike on Syria will mean the '...
      • Analysis: Are Syrian and Iranian threats just blus...
      • The Pros and Cons of Attacking Syria
      • The unbearable passivity of triangulated policies ...
      • "Unreal"
      • Self-serving posturing over Syria
      • Egypt: al Jazeera ‘National Threat,’ Bans Channel,...
      • Are We Willing to Defend Ourselves?
      • America’s Impending Defeat in Syria
      • Massive Protest Set Against 'World's Most Dangerou...
      • Cirque du Jihad
      • Obama Gets His War On
      • Syria Does Not Satisfy the Powell Doctrine
      • The Israeli Spring
      • The Implications of Obama’s Failure in Egypt
      • The Brotherhood Starts Anew in Syria
      • Interview: Khaled Abu Toameh in Hadassah Magazine
      • Where's the Coverage? Israel Surrounded by Threats
      • PROFESSOR BERES AT HARVARD: Are Israel's Actions L...
      • Don't get too excited-let us see for how long this...
      • "No Choice?"
      • Crisis: Egypt May Stop Warships Headed for Syria a...
      • SELF-SERVING POSTURING OVER SYRIA
      • Hotovely laments Likud 'schizophrenia' on two states
      • COP: 11,967 inconvenient facts
      • COP: The mystery mound where Jesus walked on water?
      • Loose Lips on Syria
      • Muslim Brotherhood's World Domination Blueprint
      • The global jihad-affiliated Abdullah Azzam Brigade...
      • Western powers 'ready to go' for military strike a...
      • The Palestinian Authority's "Israeli Affairs Commi...
      • Will Obama Really Hold Assad Accountable?
      • Al Jazeera airs fake Brotherhood injuries and deaths
      • Russia seizes the moment-good grief, stand down
      • The Muslim Brotherhood: Origins, Efficacy and Reach
      • What’s Wrong with Going into Syria
      • Israel calls on UNRWA to refrain from one-sided po...
      • Opinion: Options of War
      • Stephens: Target Assad
      • Countdown To Syria-Is Obama Ready To Start a Regio...
      • Analysis: The Regional Implications of a U.S. Stri...
      • Facing the North
      • Livni 'Undermining Israel's Interests' in Talks
      • Egypt is Where History Goes to Die
      • M Calls Al Jazeera a Homeland Security Threat
      • Who Should Clean Up the Mess?
      • TIMES OF ISRAEL PUBLISHES NONSENSE EQUATING ‘ISLAM...
      • The Impending American Defeat in Syria‏
      • Britain taking lead on Syria?
      • Destroying Islam's Holiest Shrine for Assad?
      • Britain: Muslim TV Hate Preachers "Inciting Murder"
      • COP: 33 Shocking Facts Which Show How Badly The Ec...
      • Livni and Erekat talk peace before Kalandiya violence
      • The Muslim Brotherhood: Origins, Efficacy, and Reach
      • Tunisians Renew Protests Against Islamist Government
      • Identity Politics, the Pursuit of Social Justice, ...
      • The banality of Lisa Goldman’s Israel-bashing
      • BOMBING SYRIA: WHAT'S THE GOAL?
      • The Truth About Syria
      • Update: IDF on Qalandiya: Soldiers fired afte...
      • New Oil Field Could Yield Rich Returns for Israel
      • Outrage: U.S. Returning Artifacts Looted from Iraq...
      • Update: Murdering Jews simply does count!
      • 3 Palestinians killed as IDF, Border Police come u...
      • Radicalization and Escalation‏
      • Israel: Leper or Light Unto the Nations? Part 4: W...
      • Why is Crushing the Muslim Brotherhood a Bad Thing?
      • Meeting Malka [Malki] Chana Roth, a terror victim:...
      • Opinion: A Frightening Drug
      • Bashir against the Brotherhood
      • Netanyahu disputes Fabius diagnosis that Israeli-P...
      • The Failed Grand Strategy in the Middle East
      • Obama, single handed, ignited the "Arab Spring" da...
      • American Culture: How to Reconcile the Brutal and ...
      • CNN,CNN,CNN-really now!
      • Infiltration in USA: You have been notified
      • Video: Egyptian authorities do nothing as Christia...
      • Jerusalem: Capital Cut-Up Kerry's Latest Joke
      • The bad, the worse, and the ugly
      • Insane This Way
      • "Islamophobia": a "quack pseudo-diagnosis" based o...
      • Obama on Syria: Low-quality “jaw-jaw”
      • U.S. Air Force student guide: Talk of individual l...
      • Special Forces: Obama Refused to Pull Trigger on B...
      • Assad's arsenal: 100,000 missiles
      • Erdogan: Why Did Washington Condemn My Remarks on ...
      • The Oslo Accord, a Bird's View 20 Years Later
      • ISNA Discusses Peace in Middle East with Sec. Kerr...
      • Eutopia
      • Does Abbas really want peace?
      • Egyptians Bewildered Over Support for Muslim Broth...
      • The choice in Egypt
      • The world cannot preach morality to Israel if it d...
      • Christians: On the Front Lines of Muslim Violence
      • World learns to manage without the US
      • How Close Is the U.S. to the Muslim Brotherhood?
      • Islam: Religion of Bigots
      • Livni’s Source of Desperation: Jewish Births Way U...
      • Lost: Obama Middle East Policy, 2013-2016,(1) Why ...
      • Feminist ‘Hijab Solidarity’?
      • Resetting US foreign policy
      • Don't Rescue the Muslim Brotherhood
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile