YomKippur2013

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, August 30, 2013

U.S. Attack on Syria Won't Change Anything

Posted on 11:06 AM by Unknown
Barry Rubin

Forgot about the hysteria of an impending U.S. attack on Syria. Forget about the likely self-congratulatory backslapping by policy makers and the chanting of, “USA!” by citizens. A U.S. air assault on Syria will not change anything  for the benefit of U.S. interests or even for the well-being of the Syrian people.

Clearly, it will not change the regional problems, including the U.S. support for an Islamist government in Egypt, the unstable Islamist government in Tunisia, the grim expectations for a “peace process,” the constant betrayal of the United States by the Turkish government, and the Iranian nuclear race. But beyond that, it won’t change the Syrian crisis.

Would the attack determine the outcome of a Syrian civil war, either in favor of the Iranian backed government or the Islamists favored by the United States? No. Would it by itself increase the prestige and credibility of the United States in the Middle East? No.

Let’s consider the three motives for the potential Syrian attack. One, the humanitarian motive. After perhaps 100,000 people in Syria have been killed, this addresses one percent of the casualties (namely those by chemical weapons). That might be worthwhile but leaves unaddressed the 99 percent of other casualties.

Is it really true that the Syrian government somewhat, without motive, used chemical weapons? And finally, is it really humanitarian since the rebel side is likely to be equally ferocious against minorities and people it doesn’t like? The humanitarian motive, while sincere, really doesn’t amount to very much but merely tells the Syrian government the proper way in which people can be killed.

Second, what message does America’s potential attack in Syria really send? That American power, which will be limited, is not going to be sufficient to change the course of the war. So the United States will not determine who wins and that, after all, is only thing that everyone is really interested in.

The third motive is to send a message to Iran that it won’t be able to succeed in aggression. But in fact, this too can be said to send the opposite message: that in the words of Ayatollah Khomeini in 1979, that “the United States cannot do a damn thing.”

What are the possible outcomes of this mission? The Syrian government will not be overthrown nor saved. The fate of the civil war is going to be totally outside this operation. Perhaps it will make the outcome more likely to be a diplomatic one. But again the likelihood that Russia and Iran will agree to have its client deposed is simply unlikely.

 One could argue that the attack will lead to a lower estimation of American credibility, since not much will have changed afterward, although this is not what the media will say. Imagine that the U.S. policy doesn't even have Britain on board! Obama cannot even line up America''s closest historic partner. How's that for credibility?  

It is interesting to note that in confronting Saddam Hussein, the Clinton Administration attacked Iraq at least four times in 1998 alone. But of course Hussein was only overthrown six years later by a controversial decision by another administration.

What would the best beneficial outcomes for the Obama Administration be? First, that Obama will congratulate himself on his daring use of force and not backing down to anyone. But so what? Aside from the newspaper headlines and the bounces in public opinion polls, the affect will be merely psychological and domestic. In friendly capitals, it will only show that he is willing to support the Sunni Islamists and oppose the Shia ones. In enemy capitals, there will be derision of the limited means at Obama’s disposal for affecting events.

What would be the best outcome for America? That the war will go on long enough until one side wins and that side will not be the regime.  But basically, the civil war is going to be fought out.

It might well be said that strategically, it would be better if Iran didn't win the victory by saving the regime, but frankly, a victory by radical Islamist rebels and al-Qaida is hardly a bargain. Don’t forget that in practice, an American intervention would not be on the side of easing the lot of Syrian civilians but on the side of an extremely oppressive and unstable future government winning.

In other words, it is not that there are no easy answers but there are no good answers.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The complex legality of settlements
    PETER WERTHEIM The misuse of international law as a tool of political condemnation is especially unhelpful right now.   For David Kretzmer...
  • Yup Obama has Israel's back-read on...
    U.S. spy network’s successes, failures and objectives detailed in ‘black budget’ summary By Barton Gellman and Greg M...
  • Syrian Diplomacy?
    Barry Rubin On September 11, 2013 The idea of a diplomatic solution to the Syrian crisis is ideal for the Obama Administration, but that...
  • Peace Talks: What Is Behind The Palestinian Message?
    Khaled Abu Toameh For now, the Palestinian Authority's strategy is to continue talking while at the same time blaming Israel for the l...
  • Rethinking the Two-State Solution
    PolicyWatch 1408     Giora Eiland and Martin Indyk Also available in ...
  • Eliminate Israel and replace it with an Arab-majority nation?
      Jonathan Tobin The New York Times just spent 2,300 words outlining how -- and why -- it should be done JewishWorldReview.com |   Twenty ye...
  • Libyan Muslim Brotherhood opens door to conciliation
    Khalid Mahmoud   Libyan Brotherhood deny they were against Zaidan's government since his appointment, and will decide whether to stay ...
  • Kuwait Funding Muslim Brotherhood Growth in Western Mosques
    Abigail R. Esman Special to IPT News September 13, 2013 http://www.investigativeproject.org/4160/kuwait-funding-muslim-brotherhood-growth-in...
  • Analysis: Are Syrian and Iranian threats just bluster?
    By ARIEL BEN SOLOMON   US military expert says Syria is capable of attacking Israel, as it has hundreds of...
  • British commander to Post: Russian-US plan for Syria ‘not realistic’
    YAAKOV LAPPIN 09/16/2013 Former commander of British forces in Afgha...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  September (234)
    • ▼  August (266)
      • The Obama Doctrine: Right is might
      • France: A "Secularism Charter" in Every School
      • Bombing Into Unintended Consequences in Syria
      • Into The Fray: David Harris’s ‘stunning shortsight...
      • Israel's only two options
      • Rethinking the Two-State Solution
      • The Two State Concept is Wrong
      • Egypt: Muslim Brotherhood supporters place X marks...
      • The Kurds Can Lead a Reborn Syria, At Peace With A...
      • COP: The Legacy of Liberalism
      • For It and Against It
      • Spokesman for Catholic Church in Egypt: “Shame on ...
      • Syria Claims Terrorists Behind WMD Attack Will Car...
      • Op-Ed: Terrible Days are Coming Upon Europe
      • Tension and skepticism as Obama nears Syria moment
      • Why Is Obama Contemplating Military Strike On Syri...
      • US Admin Seeks Green Light to Respond Militarily t...
      • Latest NYT Denunciation of Israel
      • Yup Obama has Israel's back-read on...
      • U.S. Attack on Syria Won't Change Anything
      • Why So Many Palestinian High-Tech Entrepreneurs Ha...
      • The Al Dura Case: White Hats, Black Hats, and Dunc...
      • Obama's bread and circuses
      • How Obama Hugged the Brotherhood to Death
      • Who are the neo-con cowboys now?
      • What Barack Obama Can Learn from Israel about Conf...
      • Iran commander: US strike on Syria will mean the '...
      • Analysis: Are Syrian and Iranian threats just blus...
      • The Pros and Cons of Attacking Syria
      • The unbearable passivity of triangulated policies ...
      • "Unreal"
      • Self-serving posturing over Syria
      • Egypt: al Jazeera ‘National Threat,’ Bans Channel,...
      • Are We Willing to Defend Ourselves?
      • America’s Impending Defeat in Syria
      • Massive Protest Set Against 'World's Most Dangerou...
      • Cirque du Jihad
      • Obama Gets His War On
      • Syria Does Not Satisfy the Powell Doctrine
      • The Israeli Spring
      • The Implications of Obama’s Failure in Egypt
      • The Brotherhood Starts Anew in Syria
      • Interview: Khaled Abu Toameh in Hadassah Magazine
      • Where's the Coverage? Israel Surrounded by Threats
      • PROFESSOR BERES AT HARVARD: Are Israel's Actions L...
      • Don't get too excited-let us see for how long this...
      • "No Choice?"
      • Crisis: Egypt May Stop Warships Headed for Syria a...
      • SELF-SERVING POSTURING OVER SYRIA
      • Hotovely laments Likud 'schizophrenia' on two states
      • COP: 11,967 inconvenient facts
      • COP: The mystery mound where Jesus walked on water?
      • Loose Lips on Syria
      • Muslim Brotherhood's World Domination Blueprint
      • The global jihad-affiliated Abdullah Azzam Brigade...
      • Western powers 'ready to go' for military strike a...
      • The Palestinian Authority's "Israeli Affairs Commi...
      • Will Obama Really Hold Assad Accountable?
      • Al Jazeera airs fake Brotherhood injuries and deaths
      • Russia seizes the moment-good grief, stand down
      • The Muslim Brotherhood: Origins, Efficacy and Reach
      • What’s Wrong with Going into Syria
      • Israel calls on UNRWA to refrain from one-sided po...
      • Opinion: Options of War
      • Stephens: Target Assad
      • Countdown To Syria-Is Obama Ready To Start a Regio...
      • Analysis: The Regional Implications of a U.S. Stri...
      • Facing the North
      • Livni 'Undermining Israel's Interests' in Talks
      • Egypt is Where History Goes to Die
      • M Calls Al Jazeera a Homeland Security Threat
      • Who Should Clean Up the Mess?
      • TIMES OF ISRAEL PUBLISHES NONSENSE EQUATING ‘ISLAM...
      • The Impending American Defeat in Syria‏
      • Britain taking lead on Syria?
      • Destroying Islam's Holiest Shrine for Assad?
      • Britain: Muslim TV Hate Preachers "Inciting Murder"
      • COP: 33 Shocking Facts Which Show How Badly The Ec...
      • Livni and Erekat talk peace before Kalandiya violence
      • The Muslim Brotherhood: Origins, Efficacy, and Reach
      • Tunisians Renew Protests Against Islamist Government
      • Identity Politics, the Pursuit of Social Justice, ...
      • The banality of Lisa Goldman’s Israel-bashing
      • BOMBING SYRIA: WHAT'S THE GOAL?
      • The Truth About Syria
      • Update: IDF on Qalandiya: Soldiers fired afte...
      • New Oil Field Could Yield Rich Returns for Israel
      • Outrage: U.S. Returning Artifacts Looted from Iraq...
      • Update: Murdering Jews simply does count!
      • 3 Palestinians killed as IDF, Border Police come u...
      • Radicalization and Escalation‏
      • Israel: Leper or Light Unto the Nations? Part 4: W...
      • Why is Crushing the Muslim Brotherhood a Bad Thing?
      • Meeting Malka [Malki] Chana Roth, a terror victim:...
      • Opinion: A Frightening Drug
      • Bashir against the Brotherhood
      • Netanyahu disputes Fabius diagnosis that Israeli-P...
      • The Failed Grand Strategy in the Middle East
      • Obama, single handed, ignited the "Arab Spring" da...
      • American Culture: How to Reconcile the Brutal and ...
      • CNN,CNN,CNN-really now!
      • Infiltration in USA: You have been notified
      • Video: Egyptian authorities do nothing as Christia...
      • Jerusalem: Capital Cut-Up Kerry's Latest Joke
      • The bad, the worse, and the ugly
      • Insane This Way
      • "Islamophobia": a "quack pseudo-diagnosis" based o...
      • Obama on Syria: Low-quality “jaw-jaw”
      • U.S. Air Force student guide: Talk of individual l...
      • Special Forces: Obama Refused to Pull Trigger on B...
      • Assad's arsenal: 100,000 missiles
      • Erdogan: Why Did Washington Condemn My Remarks on ...
      • The Oslo Accord, a Bird's View 20 Years Later
      • ISNA Discusses Peace in Middle East with Sec. Kerr...
      • Eutopia
      • Does Abbas really want peace?
      • Egyptians Bewildered Over Support for Muslim Broth...
      • The choice in Egypt
      • The world cannot preach morality to Israel if it d...
      • Christians: On the Front Lines of Muslim Violence
      • World learns to manage without the US
      • How Close Is the U.S. to the Muslim Brotherhood?
      • Islam: Religion of Bigots
      • Livni’s Source of Desperation: Jewish Births Way U...
      • Lost: Obama Middle East Policy, 2013-2016,(1) Why ...
      • Feminist ‘Hijab Solidarity’?
      • Resetting US foreign policy
      • Don't Rescue the Muslim Brotherhood
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile